LeslieWylie/review-workflow
A structured multi-panelist review workflow for the DeepSeek Harness: N panelists score in isolated subagents, blind to each other; a chair reconciles disagreement by anchor match then Δ-level adjudication; an independent critic audits the process. Works for design, code, paper or project review.
Listed
1
Workflow
Bundle verified
What it does
A structured multi-panelist review workflow for the DeepSeek Harness: N panelists score in isolated subagents, blind to each other; a chair reconciles disagreement by anchor match then Δ-level adjudication; an independent critic audits the process. Works for design, code, paper or project review.
Best for
- Design, code, paper, or project reviews that need multiple independent scores and explicit disagreement resolution.
- Teams that can supply a project-specific rubric, anchored scoring criteria, templates, thresholds, and completeness checklist.
- High-accountability reviews that benefit from saved intermediate artifacts and an independent process audit.
Not ideal for
- Quick informal feedback where a six-step, checkpointed review process would add unnecessary overhead.
- Projects that do not have the required rubric, review templates, thresholds, and checklist.
- Reviews that cannot run isolated panelist and critic subagents.
README
dsh-review-workflow · 通用多评委评审工作流
这是什么
一个通用多评委评审工作流 skill。从 collaboration-review 流程脱敏泛化而来，适用于任何需要结构化评审的场景——项目评审、论文审稿、代码审查、设计评审等。
核心能力
| 模块 | 内容 |
|---|---|
| 6 步流程 + 6 Checkpoint | 材料完整性检查 → 准备 bundle → N 评委并行打分 → 聚合分歧 → Critic 复核 → 出最终决定 |
| N 评委并行独立打分 | 评委用独立 subagent 运行，互不可见，防止偏见影响 |
| 锚定一致性检查 | 两阶段分歧处理：锚定匹配 → Δ 等级裁决 |
| Critic 独立复核 | 独立 subagent 复核流程合规性，挑战理据不足 |
| 复评支持 | 增量复评：只重评修改项相关维度 |
| 可配置 | 评审维度、评分标准、模板、评委数量均可配置 |
安装
dsh plugin --profile web add "github:LeslieWylie/review-workflow"
重启后，在任意会话中加载 skill：
load review-workflow
所需配置
本 skill 需要项目级配置（放在项目自己的 skill 或配置文件中）：
| 配置项 | 说明 | 示例 |
|---|---|---|
| rubric | 评审维度与评分标准 | 5 维度 5 分制，每维度有锚定描述 |
| bundle 模板 | 评审材料包模板 | bundle.md |
| panelist prompt | 评委 prompt 模板 | panelist-prompt.md |
| aggregation 模板 | 聚合报告模板 | aggregation.md |
| critic 模板 | 复核报告模板 | critic-report.md |
| checklist | 材料完整性检查清单 | proposal-checklist.md |
| panelist 数量 | 评委人数 | 2 |
| 评分阈值 | 各维度通过/不通过阈值 | ≥3/5 |
设计原则
- 场景无关：只定义评审流程骨架。具体的评审维度、评分标准、模板由项目提供
- 角色隔离：评委独立运行、Critic 独立 session，防止偏见
- Checkpoint 强制：每步有 checkpoint，未过不进入下一步
- 可审计：所有中间产物存盘，可追溯
脱敏声明
本插件从内部分协作评审流程泛化提取，已移除所有内部项目引用（具体机构名称、模型名称、内部工具路径等）。
更新日志
见 CHANGELOG.md。
许可证
MIT
Frequently Asked QuestionsFAQ
Use the verified command dsh plugin --profile default add github:LeslieWylie/review-workflow in a DSH-enabled shell. The command resolves the public package metadata and keeps the plugin attached to the catalog identity shown on this page.
Compatibility follows the bundle and profile status shown above. If a profile is not detected, keep the plugin disabled there and check the repository documentation before enabling it in production.
The GitHub link and activity metadata are the source of truth for releases and maintenance. Revisit this page after a new release to confirm the catalog has observed the latest version.